Water scarcity footprint: The case study of the
Italian electricity mix
Accepted 7th
November, 2018
Alessia Gargiulo*, Maria Leonor Carvalho and
Pierpaolo Girardi
Sustainable Development and Energy Sources
Department, RSE - Ricerca sul Sistema Energetico, Via Rubattino 54, 20134 Milan,
Italy.
Water footprint of energy system is a topic of main concern in the framework of
sustainable development. Recently a new framework has been introduced by ISO
14046:2014, integrating water footprint assessment in the Life Cycle Assessment
(LCA) methodology (ISO 14040:2006). The goal of the present work is to assess
the water footprint of Italian electricity mix, using (LCA) methodology. The
case study was aimed also to point out the needs for data improvements. For the
Italian electricity mix, more than one hundred types of power plants were
considered. In accordance with ISO 14046, first, water consumptions along the
entire electricity life cycle were evaluated. Then the impact of the water
consumptions on local water scarcity (water scarcity footprint) was assessed. To
this end, among impact assessment methods available in literature, we selected
AWARE which is the result of a recent process of harmonization carried out by
the Water Use Life Cycle Assessment (WULCA) working group. Results were also
compared with the results of another impact assessment method. Although the
hydropower contributes 18.5% of the national electricity mix, it dominates the
overall water consumption (over 66%) and water scarcity footprint (78%). On the
other hand, natural gas plants with a contribution to the mix of 28% are
responsible for only 3.51% of water consumption and for around 3.6% of water
footprint. With a share of 7% in the mix, photovoltaic contribution is 3.5% of
the consumption and 2.7% of the water footprint. Imported electricity covers 14%
of the mix and accounts for 17% of consumption, but only 8% of the water
footprint. The application of the WAVE method leads to similar conclusions. The
allocation of impact of hydropower to the various uses in multi-purpose
reservoirs remains a topic to be further investigated. Moreover for hydropower a
monthly assessment should be implemented in consideration of temporal
variability of water consumption and availability. The study provided first
results of water footprint assessment of Italian electricity mix according to
ISO 14046 and can support water footprint assessment in a wide field of LCA
applications, since electricity is often the most water intensive process in the
life cycle of industrial products. The use of primary data for cooling systems
led to more accurate evaluation and is recommendable for similar studies. The
analysis of water consumption by geographic location put in evidence the need
for data improvements especially for studies aimed at comparisons between
different technologies or alternative fuel supply chains.
Key words:
Water footprint, LCA, electricity mix, AWARE.
This is an open access article
published under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution
License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and
reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is
properly cited.
Cite this article as:
Gargiulo A, Carvalho ML, Girardi P (2018). Water scarcity footprint: The case
study of the Italian electricity mix. Acad. J. Environ. Sci. 6(11): 288-300.